Buy vs. Building Your Next Home - Detailed Cost Breakdown

Choosing whether to buy or build your next home can feel like a huge fork in the road. One side offers speed and simplicity: pick a home, close, move in. The other side promises creative control and a space that actually matches how you live, right down to the custom coffee nook or bedroom layout you’ve sketched for years. But what does each path cost—and how do you know which one really makes sense for your budget and priorities?

We’ve broken down key numbers, region insights, and honest pros and cons, using latest state-by-state research.

So, is it actually cheaper to buy or build your home?

Let’s cut straight to the numbers: across the entire U.S., building a new home comes in at about $421,000, while the median price for buying an existing, single-family home is roughly $415,000. On the surface, there’s only a $6,000 difference—hardly the stuff of life-changing decisions.

But that national average masks some big swings depending on location: In certain states, building is actually hundreds of thousands cheaper than buying. In others, building can cost $100,000 or more above the price of simply purchasing.

Here’s how to think about it:

• If you’re in an area where home prices are sky-high (think Hawaii or California), building can sometimes be a surprising bargain.
• But if you live where existing homes are priced more moderately, sticking with an already-built house could spare you a much larger bill.

A few quick examples:

• Hawaii: $494,000 cheaper to build
• California: $205,000 cheaper to build
• Colorado: $108,000 cheaper to build
• Pennsylvania: $183,000 more expensive to build
• Ohio: $178,000 more expensive to build

But there’s more than just the sticker price that should factor into cost

At this point, it’s easy to say, “I’ll just go with whichever option is cheapest.” However, the numbers reflected above only reflect upfront home building costs. So here are a few extra reasons building may still make sense, even if it costs a bit more up front:

• Less maintenance (and fewer headaches) in the early years. With a brand new home, everything from the roof to the water heater starts its life on day one. That means you’re not bracing for a surprise $10,000 roof replacement or a furnace that fails the first winter. All homes need upkeep, but new ones tend to give you a breather.
• You can build for your routines—not the previous owner’s. A new build means you call the shots. Love to cook? Get the kitchen flow you’ve always wanted. Need a real home office (not just a desk jammed in a corner)? You can design it. This isn’t just about comfort—it can prevent you from spending more down the road to retrofit a space that never fit your life to begin with.
• Energy and efficiency advantages. Many older homes aren’t winning any awards for insulation or efficiency. When you’re building new, you can prioritize everything from better windows to EV chargers and solar setups—improvements that help your home run smoother and can chip away at monthly bills for years to come.
• Opportunities for extra safety (and sometimes lower insurance). Building new lets you add features that make insurance companies—and you—sleep better: wildfire-resistant building materials, hurricane windows, elevated foundations, and smart tech. These choices can sometimes get you better rates and fewer worries.

All of the above suggest that a custom built home has the potential to save you money in the long run.

Design a Home That’s Uniquely Yours

Block can help you achieve your renovation goals and bring your dream remodel to life with price assurance and expert support.

Get Started

Understanding the largest expenses when building a home

Every decision—from the sourcing of tiles to the elevation of ceilings will impact your bottom line. However, some elements of building a new home will naturally have a larger impact. These are:

• Labor and construction (30–40%): The biggest share of your budget—covers everything from skilled trades (like framers and electricians) to general site work and day-to-day build costs.
• Materials and finishes (25–35%): Includes lumber, windows, doors, roofing, flooring, cabinets, tiles, fixtures, and all the “visible” ingredients; high-end selections can quickly increase this portion.
• Land purchase and site preparation (10–20%): The price of your lot, plus grading, tree clearing, soil testing, utility hookups, and permit fees; the cost swings widely by location and lot conditions.
• Mechanical systems (10–15%): Covers plumbing, electrical, HVAC, and any extras like smart home wiring or solar prep; essential to comfort, but easy to overlook until later stages.
• Design, engineering, and permits (5–10%): Payment for architects, structural engineers, site surveys, and local building fees; custom designs and complex sites generally come in on the higher end.
• Contingency and miscellaneous (5–10%): Your financial cushion for surprises—covers unexpected site conditions, price changes, or tweaks you decide to make mid-project.

Choosing your lot: a decision with big (and sometimes hidden) cost impact

Picking your lot is one of the most important steps of the entire building process—and it’s often where costly surprises come from. While it’s tempting to jump at a lower-priced plot or a location with a killer view, the real costs of building on a piece of land go well beyond that sticker price.

• Site work and preparation can add up fast. A lot that needs heavy grading, tree clearing, or complex drainage solutions will almost always cost more (sometimes much more) than a flat, build-ready parcel.
• Soil and access matter. If your lot has tricky soil that needs reinforcement or is off a narrow access road, you'll likely spend extra on foundations, driveway work, or even specialty equipment to simply get materials to the site.
• Utility connections aren’t just paperwork. Plots in established neighborhoods may already have gas, water, and electric hookups nearby, while rural or “raw” lots might require digging lines, installing septic, or even drilling a well—all of which can run into the tens of thousands.
• Regulations and requirements can slow you down. Some lots are subject to flood zones, wetlands rules, historic district restrictions, HOA oversight, or minimum setback rules. Each can limit what you can build—and what it will cost to get approval.

Before you fall in love with a parcel, work with a professional to do your due diligence. Ordering a survey, soil test, and a check of utility access can save you from finding out too late that your “bargain” lot comes with tens of thousands in extra costs or months of red tape.

Smart, simple ways to avoid building budget “blow-ups”

Here’s something we hear from homeowners all the time: “We thought we had a budget, but it just kept growing.” Custom builds rarely spiral out of control all at once—it’s usually a pile-up of small choices or late changes that sneak up over weeks and months.

Some ways to keep your budget realistic (and sleep a little easier):

• Decide upfront what matters most. Set your must-haves and “nice but not vital”—if everything is a priority, the costs multiply fast; take the time to define what truly matters to you before you fall in love with every possible upgrade.
• Don’t over-complicate your footprint. Homes with simple shapes and rooflines are almost always easier, faster, and less costly to build and maintain; rooms that “pop out” or zig-zag layouts usually cost more in both framing and finishing—clean lines keep budgets healthier.
• Minimize expensive moves. For remodels and new builds alike, moving plumbing (think: kitchens and bathrooms) can add up quickly; place bathrooms and kitchens back-to-back or stack them between floors to keep plumbing lines—and costs—efficient.
• Consider your lot carefully. Not every lot is a bargain, even if the sticker price is low; lots with steep slopes, hard-to-access locations, or tricky soil often require extra prep, grading, or utility work that can add thousands before you break ground.
• Pick your tile, windows, and fixtures early. These items can have long lead times—choosing them ahead means fewer panicked, last-minute (and usually pricier) decisions; setting your finish selections early helps your contractor lock in prices and prevents delays that can quickly snowball on your timeline and budget.
• Read your proposal closely. Allowances (budget placeholders) can hide cost spikes—ask for specifics about what’s included, what isn’t, and what the “standard” finish actually looks like; if you’re not sure what an “allowance” covers, get clarity before moving forward.
• Set aside a contingency. Treat this as a must, not a maybe—usually, 10-20% extra is a solid cushion for weather, supply hiccups, or the unexpected; a well-planned buffer keeps surprises manageable and supports smarter decision-making under pressure.

Curious about the cost of custom building in your state?

Here’s the latest state-by-state breakdown for house building costs. Use these numbers as a starting guide, but always check your local prices, especially for land, labor, and permits.

Source: https://www.storagecafe.com/blog/is-it-cheaper-to-build-or-buy-a-house-in-the-us/

Finding the right contractor—Block Renovation can help

So, you’ve made your call (or you’re close): whether you land on building, buying and remodeling, or simply updating your existing place, finding the right contractor is what turns plans into reality.

Block Renovation matches homeowners with top, vetted contractors who bring deep experience—and care—into every project. The best builds (and buys) are the ones where the homeowner feels both confident and in control, from budget to final walkthrough. With the right partnership, you can sidestep many of the typical headaches and focus on the real goal: making a home that’s truly your own.

Still unsure whether building is right for you? Want to check your local numbers? Need help prepping for a contractor search? Reach out to Block and start your journey with clear, honest answers—not just guesses.

Remodel with confidence through Block

Connect to vetted local contractors

We only work with top-tier, thoroughly vetted contractors

Get expert guidance

Our project planners offer expert advice, scope review, and ongoing support as needed

Enjoy peace of mind throughout your renovation

Secure payment system puts you in control and protects your remodel

Get Started